Are you in the market for a new, reliable, and fuel-efficient small SUV? Consumer Reports has you covered with their latest list of top-rated options. But here's where it gets controversial... While some may opt for the tried and true Toyota, others might be surprised to discover that there are plenty of exciting and different options available. So, let's dive into the world of small SUVs and explore the most reliable and fuel-efficient models on the market, according to Consumer Reports.
Subcompact Crossovers
Subaru Crosstrek
If you're looking for the smallest and most affordable crossover, the Subaru Crosstrek is a strong contender. It's the most off-road-capable of the three, but it's also the highest-rated subcompact crossover that Consumer Reports has tested. However, Subaru does offer the Crosstrek as a hybrid, which is $7,000 more expensive than the base model. So, you might want to consider if the extra cost is worth it.
Toyota Corolla Cross
The Toyota Corolla Cross is another great option for those seeking a subcompact crossover. While it may not be as off-road-ready as the Crosstrek, it still gets pretty good gas mileage. If you can justify the extra cost, the hybrid version is even better on gas. However, neither version is particularly quick, and the interior is subpar, even in the nicest version.
Kia Seltos
The Kia Seltos is the budget-friendly option of the three, undercutting both the base Crosstrek and Corolla Cross by several thousand dollars. While all-wheel drive doesn't come standard, a good set of tires can make up for it. The Seltos is a great choice for those on a tight budget.
Luxury Subcompact Crossovers
Lexus UX
For those seeking a subcompact crossover with a more premium interior, the Lexus UX is a great choice. It's both comfortable and reliable, and it returns great gas mileage as a hybrid. However, the cabin is surprisingly cramped, especially in the second row.
BMW X1 and X2
The BMW X1 and X2 may be surprising to see on a list of reliable luxury SUVs, but BMW has been working on its reliability for years, and it's paying off. The X1 is Consumer Reports' highest-rated luxury subcompact, while the X2 is essentially an X1 with more coupe-like styling and a slightly higher base price. The style may be worth the extra money, but we'd probably stick with the X1's more practical shape.
Compact Crossovers
Subaru Forester
If you're looking for an SUV that's a little larger than the subcompacts, the Subaru Forester is a great option. The hybrid or plug-in hybrid versions are highly recommended, and the Forester Hybrid is the clear number one, according to Consumer Reports. The more conventionally powered Forester is also a strong contender.
Honda CR-V, Kia Sportage, Hyundai Tucson, Mazda CX-50, and Ford Escape
The Honda CR-V Hybrid, Kia Sportage Hybrid and Plug-In Hybrid, and Hyundai Tucson Hybrid are all excellent buys, and they're so evenly matched that you can pretty much just pick the one you like best. The Mazda CX-50 Hybrid is the sportier and slightly more premium pick of this bunch, while the Ford Escape Hybrid is showing its age but still holds up better than expected against its newer competition.
Luxury Compact Crossovers
Lexus NX
The Lexus NX is Consumer Reports' top-rated choice in the compact luxury SUV segment. Just be sure to go with the hybrid if you can find one. The mechanical twin of the Toyota RAV4, the NX is a great option for those seeking a premium crossover.
BMW X3 and Mini Cooper Countryman
The BMW X3 is one of CR's top-rated luxury compacts, despite its controversial design. The Mini Cooper Countryman is a quirky and fun option, and it slightly outscores its platform-mate, the BMW X1, when it comes to reliability. At the very least, it's worth a test drive.
So, there you have it! Consumer Reports has provided a comprehensive list of the most reliable and fuel-efficient small SUVs on the market. But remember, the best choice for you will depend on your specific needs and preferences. So, don't be afraid to explore your options and find the perfect crossover for you.
